This post was inspired by The Mapmaker’s Children by Sarah McCoy, a novel about two women who are connected by an Underground Railroad doll. Join From Left to Write on May 19th as we discuss The Mapmaker’s Children.
Since I’m currently on my OB/GYN rotation, babies, fertility, lady parts, and all that goodness have been stuck on my mind like no other these past few weeks (if only because it’s the bulk of what I’ve been studying). So it was mildly fitting that The Mapmaker’s Children paralleled and drew connections between two women who both couldn’t have children. It’s set in two different time periods, and I looked forward to reading the parts on Sarah Brown every time. (In my opinion,) Eden, the protagonist in “present-day” is not quite so likable.
Strong female characters are awesome in my book, and I loved that Sarah so staunchly stood up for what she believed in, and how she held fast to her morals and her beliefs throughout. I think Sarah McCoy did an amazing job in writing this.
I’ll be honest though–this book broke my heart. (Yes, I’m a total sap. I blame all the hormones I’ve been surrounded by on a daily basis.) It was beautifully written, and since I don’t like spoiling stories for people, if you plan on reading this book and don’t want a part of the story ruined for you, mayyybe think about not reading the rest of this post. (I went off-roading on a major tangent, but still.)
For everyone else, let’s keep on truckin’!
This book really drives home the significance of communication, and how important that is in relationships, in working with others, and in meeting a common goal.
When I got stuck in my first relationship and couldn’t leave, I committed my thoughts to paper and didn’t tell anyone what was going on. I’ve kept journals for most of my life, so writing was what I’d always been familiar with, and it became my escape. I was (and probably still am) terrible with communicating, especially through the spoken word, so it’s something I continue to work on every day.
It made me recall once upon a time in another life, when I was trading emails much like she was sending letters back and forth with Ricky.
I’ve known all along that you and I are/were basically best friends and have pretty much a perfect connection that goes far and beyond anything I’ve ever felt with anyone.”
(That isn’t from the book, but it could’ve been.) It made me wonder…if she’d just voiced her concerns and told him from the start that she couldn’t have children, would things have turned out differently?
But that’s easy for me to say, and much easier said than done.
I was incredibly impressed by how well they worked with each other through all the hardships that came their way, even despite the misunderstandings that I feel would cause most present-day individuals to react in a much more immature fashion.
I’ve never understood the reasoning behind getting angry with someone for telling the truth in response to something you’ve asked them.
Long long ago, I adopted the habit of never asking someone something unless I really wanted to hear the response, and perhaps that was the same for Sarah. Maybe leaving it as it was would hurt less than telling him and potentially being rejected based on that, but as a bystander, I really feel that finding that sort of connection with someone is incredibly rare. When/If you find that, you want to hold on to it.
- Have you heard of or read The Mapmaker’s Children?
- How do you best communicate with others? Is it through your actions, your words, in writing…?
- How do you decide whether something is worth fighting for, or letting go?
- Do you know what song the title of this post is from? :] I’ve heard this song so many times but never knew the title!
12 comments
Skip to comment form
I usually decide to let go when someone or something brings me more pain than joy. Always a hard decision to make, but I find that the heart always heals and I’m stronger for it. Nice post darling!
Author
Thanks, Chloe! :] That’s a good way to go with it (and I think that tends to be what I do as well)! Time definitely helps with the healing, and I think we learn something from each bad experience!
I think the anger that comes from hearing the truth is really denial. Because deep in our hearts, we know it is true, and we don’t want to accept it.
I’m with you on this book. ALL THE FEELS. My heart was breaking for Freddy, because he never stopped loving her.
Author
I’d definitely agree with you there. :[ My heart pretty much shattered whilst reading this book. All the feels indeed! ;_;
For me Eden was just as like able as Sarah, having been through a miscarriage and infertility, well those things can make you mean, your emotions are a roller coaster, and you aren’t the same person you once were. I think we saw Eden ride part of the most difficult part of her journey, and that is finding acceptance.
For me I know something is worth fighting for when I know it’s something I can’t live without…but things like relationships, sometimes they need space for you to realize that.
Kelly @ Cupcake Kelly’s recently posted…The Mapmaker’s Children: Small Town Living
Author
That’s a really good point! I don’t think I’d ever be able to empathize with Eden since I absolutely do not want kids, but I’m really glad that she found acceptance (+ became a mother figure to Cleo! :] )!
Very true. Giving someone space does tend to help people to realize what it is that they really want.
I didn’t mind Eden’s character at all. I’ve never had any issues with infertility, so I don’t know what it’s like for someone who’s been through what she has. I’m just glad that her husband saw through her pain for what it truly was.
Thien-Kim recently posted…Giveaway: Deborah Harkness’ Book of Life Bundle!
Author
I couldn’t find any way to relate to Eden, but I’m really glad her husband was so patient and loving too–I felt so bad for him throughout the book.
I’m in complete agreement about Sarah versus Eden. I loved this book and will pass it on to others, but mainly because the sections about Sarah Brown were so fascinating!
Kate recently posted…The Mysteries Hidden Within Old Houses
Author
Agreed! I guess I just could not relate to Eden in any way, but I really loved reading about Sarah’s story! :] I’ll definitely be recommending this to others as well!
I haven’t heard about Virtual Book Club, but I will check it out! I’m not the best communicator (but I’m learning). My typical sentiment is “why bother… they won’t get it… I will just go and read a book instead …”
Eva recently posted…Ten Commandments of a Ferocious Reader
Author
Ooo, it’s a lot of fun! <3 We're on "summer vacation" at the moment, but I believe we're scheduled to pick up again in August (the book I think we were thinking of doing is The Little Paris Bookshop! :P )!
I'm learning to be better at communicating too--it's a never-ending process!